Sunday, December 6, 2009

Catholic Church is A State-Sanctioned Paedophile Ring

By Jennifer O’Connell

There is some good news out of the Murphy Report. Since 2008, the Church has been putting prospective seminarians through rigorous psychological testing.

The bad news is that they don’t actually look for signs of paedophilia.

Instead, the testing is focused on what the Vatican coyly calls  “areas of immaturity in development” including things like "rigidity of character; lack of loyalty; uncertain sexual identity; deep-seated homosexual tendencies, etc."  

The Report quotes a recent judgment of the Congregation for Divine Worship which states that: “The ordination .. of homosexual persons or those with a homosexual tendency is absolutely inadvisable and imprudent and .. very risky.”

On paedophilia, there is not a word. But that’s hardly surprising.

Since the 1920s, paedophilia has been the dirty little secret the Church goes to extraordinary lengths to cover up. The Vatican’s guidance on how to deal with what it referred to as “the worst crime” was first published in 1922, in Latin. It was republished in 1962 - once again, in Latin.

This document is shrouded in the utmost secrecy, issued with strict instructions that it is to be stored in a special archive. So confidential is it, in fact, that Cardinal Desmond Connell claims he has never seen it.

This gives a hint as to why it doesn’t really matter what the Garda investigation, instigated by Archbishop Diarmuid Martin, into the question of whether a paedophile ring operated within the Catholic Church, eventually finds.

Of course, there is plenty of evidence that, at a mechanical level, some kind of paedophile ring did indeed operate. The Report recounts how “Fr Carney and Fr McCarthy abused children during their visits to children’s homes”; how the same Fr Carney abused children at swimming pools, and was sometimes accompanied on these outings by a convicted paedophile, Fr Patrick Maguire. 

Later, the report reveals how, when the priest it identifies as Fr ‘Ioannes’ was being investigated for the abuse of a young boy, Fr Boland - who was not in the diocese - turned up at the young boy’s home offering comfort, and abused the boy himself.

So at the very least, individual priests were giving one another a friendly nudge in the direction of every vulnerable, accessible, already-broken boy or girl.

But far, far more troubling are the ways in which the Church appeared to almost institutionalise paedophilia, which it seems – in stark contrast to its unflinching views on homosexuality - to regard as a weakness that is treatable, and ultimately forgivable.

It would be comforting to think that the decades of inaction on child abuse were a result of the Church’s naivety about all matters sexual. But it would be wrong.

Naivety cannot explain the evidence ignored; the complaints not investigated; the incidents of ‘mental reservation’; the secret payouts; the collusion between the Church leaders, the gardai and the health board to protect the reputations, the livelihoods, and even the access to a fresh supply of children, of the abusers.

In effect, the Catholic Church has been at the centre for many years of what is a large-scale, state-sanctioned, paedophile ring.

This is not simply hyperbole: what is a paedophile ring, if it is not a group of people who co-operate with one another to facilitate the widespread sexual abuse of children?

Because that is exactly what happened. With the collusion of the Vatican, Irish Church leaders, senior gardai and individuals within the health boards, paedophiles were allowed to roam scout halls, hospital corridors, swimming pool changing rooms, institutions, classrooms and even private homes in search of vulnerable young flesh.

When a complaint was made, they were moved on to a new area and a new supply of children. To their new colleagues and parishoners, it was made clear that no questions were to be asked, and none would be answered.

For many years the Church even promulgated the myth perpetuated by all paedophile operations – that child abuse is ‘not unusual’; it is a relatively harmless rite of passage; something you might – as one handwritten Diocesan memo puts it – “have a word .. about at some stage”.

Open any page in the second part of the report, and the extent of the collusion and cover-up comes spilling out.

Take Father James McNamee, the priest who ran his own kind of Turkish bath in two swimming pools at his house in Crumlin, one indoors and one outdoors, which were exclusively for the use of boys.

Confronted in the late 1970s about concerns that had been frolicking naked with boys, Father McNamee announced he wanted to retire, but was urged to stay on for a further six months, to “avoid damage to his reputation.” When he was dispatched down to the Carmelite nuns in Delgany, who were not told by Cardinal Connell or Bishop Murray of the reasons for his transfer, he rediscovered the joys of swimming, regularly taking groups of young boys down to Brittas Bay.

Or take the dangerous recidivist paedophile, Father Maguire, who abused children in Japan, Ireland and England, and was sent by way of damage limitation on “missionary promotion work” in schools around the country, to minimize his opportunity to “establish relationships which might be dangerous”.

Appallingly, it wasn’t just the church authorities who were guilty of such collusion.

In 1960, the gardai were contacted by Scotland Yard about a photographic film that had been sent to England for developing by the then-chaplain of Our Lady’s Hospital, Father ‘Edmondus’. The images on the negatives were of the private parts of girls aged ten or eleven.

The Garda Commissioner immediately decided there wasn’t enough evidence to conduct an investigation – and handed the file back to Archbishop McQuaid. McQuaid interviewed Fr Edmondus, and concluded that they were simply “art photos’’ expressing “wonderment” about the female form, and that to send the priest on retreat would “defame him”.

Edmondus went on to serve a jail term for abusing a 9-year-old girl in Wicklow, and abused countless other children, including Marie Collins.

And on it goes.

Father Patrick Maguire, who was sent home from Japan after abusing a number of children there – incidents which the Society of Saint Columban regarded as “not that unusual”, and his Church-appointed psychiatrist put down to his “loneliness in a foreign country” – and went on to abuse many more than 100 children over the next 20 years.  Self-confessed abuser Father ‘Ioannes’, who got a personal recommendation from Cardinal Connell to a parish in San Diego describing him as “an excellent priest in many ways”. 

Yet of all the sordid details collated about these disgusting men in this ruined organisation, it is the frequency with which one statement is repeated that nauseates more than anything else. “Yet again, the emphasis was on the avoidance of scandal and the protection of the priest’s reputation rather than the protection of children.”

All week, supporters of the Church have been making the predictable calls to stop looking back and look forward.

But we haven’t even properly begun to look back. This Report only covers the Archdiocese of Dublin. It doesn’t even cover all the abusers in the Archdiocese of Dublin – merely a representative sample of some 46 against whom complaints were made.

This is only the tip of a very large, very ugly and – from the Church’s point of view – very ominous iceberg.

First published in The Sunday Business Post on December 6, 2009


  1. Abuse in School 100 Times Worse than by Priests

    April 1, 2010 (LifeSiteNews)
    Charol Shakeshaft, researcher of 2004 study prepared for the U.S. Dept of Education, "physical sexual abuse of students in schools is likely more than 100xs the abuse by priests"
    2004 study most accurate data available at this time indicates nearly 9.6% of students are targets of educator sexual misconduct
    6 credible cases of clerical sexual abuse in 2009 reported in the bishops annual audit- 65,000,000 members'

    Sexual Abuse of Minors in Protestant Churches
    By Father Jonathan Morris
    (Fox News) The mainstream media has all but ignored the recent Associated Press report that the 3 major insurance companies for Protestant Churches in America say they typically receive 260 reports each year of minors being sexually abused by Protestant clergy, staff, or other church-related relationships.'
    260 Protestant Incidents to 9 in the Catholic Church!
    But Prots are Jew friendly. Kosher media is selective.

    2002, Christian Science Monitor on national survey results by Christian Ministry Resources

    Despite headlines focusing on the priest pedophile problem in the Catholic Church, most US churches being hit with child sexual-abuse allegations are Protestant.

    Penn State professor Philip Jenkins, on Pedophiles & Priests:
    0.2 & 1.7 percent of Catholic priests are pedophiles.
    Protestant Clergy Ranges between 2- 3%.'

    1. all of these references you have provided are from a partisan, right-wing propaganda source that obtains their data by questionable means. They are therefore invalid.

      in the future, please think twice before posting this misinformative garbage online.

  2. Former Anonymous: your comments are beside the point. And besides, Protestant abusers, according to your reference, are reported to the police. Catholic abusers are reported to the Church. The point is, the Catholic Church has colluded to keep this ongoing criminal behavior secret, and have facilitated rather than stopped it. Since they act in secrecy, your percentages are not accurate. Which makes your comment completely beside the point.

    I wonder if one of the problems of the Catholic Church is the way they are taught to see themselves, and their parishioners. The priests are the shepherds, and the church-goers are the flock. Shepherds are important. Flocks are -- for the purpose of harvesting meat and wool. If a shepherd, because he is lonely, or needy, screws a sheep, why does that matter, except in that it may harm the reputation of the shepherd? I think it is this view of themselves as being above, and more important, and more holy, and more entitled, than the people they are supposedly serving, which allows them so easily to behave in a criminal manner toward the youngest members of their "flocks," and respond with secrecy facilitation to "errors" on the part of the "shepherd."

    I don't see a solution for this. The whole culture of the church would have to change in order to solve it.

  3. And the reason the Catholic church frowns on birth control? More sheep for the shepards, of course. And these particular sheep are more easily accessible as they are less "wanted" in the first place. Think this is far fetched? Think again. It is truly despicable.

  4. According to Wikipedia the legal Age of Consent in Vatican City is 12.

  5. Birth control is against the natural law. It is evil.

    1. Humans aren't supposed to fly. Would riding in an airplane be considered evil? I guess those vaccines you've been subjected to would also be evil; coursing through your veins. Anti-biotics would be evil, riding in a car would be evil, and last but not least; Using a computer would be evil. Step out of the Dark Ages, jackass.

  6. Jennifer O’Connell: "the Catholic Church has been at the centre for many years of what is a large-scale, state-sanctioned, paedophile ring"
    Jct: What do expect from a celibate priesthood?
    - Motive : celibacy, these are the horniest guys on the planet, they can't even tickle their own tootoos.
    - Opportunity: Every kid has to confess his masturbation "mortal sin" weekly before being able go to communion with everyone else. Just like when a single woman doesn' t to to communion. No one thinks her mortal sin is killing someone, stealing from someone, slandering someone, they all know it's the mortal sin of loving someone without the priests' blessing.
    - Means: A nice dark confessional where junior and the priest can talk about masturbation together. Boy, it was bad enough as a boy, I wonder what it was like talking about masturbation with their priest for the girls? Jesus never had confessional with a priest as intermediary. They made up the confessional so they've a nice quiet secluded place to talk with kids about the mortal sin of "tickling their tootoos."
    So, motive: celibacy; opportunity: tickling tootoos mortal sin, means: the confessional.
    Get rid of the means, the confessional that Jesus never had, and it all goes normal.
    Get rid of the opportunity too; the God I worship doesn't care what you do with your tootoo.
    May as well get rid of celibacy too.

  7. i truthfully enjoy your own writing kind, very remarkable,
    don’t give up as well as keep writing due to the fact that it simply just worth to follow it.
    looking forward to see a whole lot more of your current well written articles, enjoy your day

  8. I would wish to thank you for that efforts you've got created in writing this post. I am hoping the exact same best perform from you in the potential as well. In reality your inventive writing skills has inspired me to start my own blog now.

  9. i truthfully enjoy your own writing kind, very remarkable,
    don’t give up as well as keep writing due to the fact that it simply just worth to follow it. looking forward to see a whole lot more of your current well written articles, enjoy your day
    London Chartered Accountants

  10. thanks for posting, the church certainly has its scandals.

  11. what an interesting story it is! I'm sure you must have invested a lot of time in investigating the details which are so astonishing. Thanks for sharing this nice blog articles.

  12. Increase credit score and save money. Your credit score largely determines the lenders available and the interest rate at which they will lend. Fix credit and expand the number of lenders willing to compete for your loan.

  13. When left unresolved this concern may snowball into a larger crisis paydayloans many those who experience low credit score feel
    isolated within their position.

  14. Hey! Do you know if they make any plugins to
    safeguard against hackers? I'm kinda paranoid about losing everything I've worked hard
    on. Any tips?

    Visit my web page ...

  15. Thank you a great deal with regard to expressing! Anyone deliver a great deal of valuable tips and advice. Economic planning is critical in addition to everybody ought to do the item - also start out while very young. But, it's just as crucial that you learn that we now have solutions as soon as folks require funds rapidly for instance receiving

  16. Your blog is extremely brilliant especially the quality content is really

  17. I am really appreciating very much by seeing your interesting posts.paydayloan

  18. Cheers! You have really allured me; I have no words to explain my feelings about your post.
    cash advance

  19. Good article, your all provided information is all right, keep your blogs on- auto insurance

  20. I am glad to see such amazing things at one place, how did you do this? I am still surprised. car insurence

  21. I went over this website and I conceive you've got a large number of splendid information,oro gold reviews

  22. Hello! After browsing some amongst the post I felt this is totally new to me. Anyhow, I’m absolutely happy to find this. Folsom auto repair

  23. Hey very nice blog!! Man you have done the Amazing efforts to make this blog... I will surely bookmark your blog. emergency electrical Cary North Carolina

  24. I extremely LOVE this blog!! I just desire I will get more posts for great information. Charlotte landscape

  25. Your style is so exclusive compared to other individuals. Thank you for posting when you have the chance, guess I would just make this bookmarked. hvac Sierra Vista

  26. The blog is good enough I again n again read day loans

  27. Excellent post guys! Your blog is attention-grabbing! Keep continuing the good work! Overland Park auto repair

  28. Hi guys!! This is actually interesting post, from every point of view it is really outstanding. kitchen remodel Moore reviews

  29. I really didn’t know all these things before which you have informed us through your best writing. triton tank

  30. Sufficient knowledge you have given to us buddies, I am really so happy to see such awesome blog. sigelei 150w box mod

  31. Hmmm, Your writing and entertaining style is so awesome, keep it up buddies!

  32. Excellent blog here. It’s out-of-the-way quality writing. If truth be told I appreciate the people like you! Take care Jupiter pediatric dentists

  33. I went over this website and I conceive you've got a large number of splendid information,pay day loans

  34. Really amazing blog, I’d love to discover some extra information.Entrepreneur Mark Curry

  35. cheap nba jerseys,
    ferragamo shoes,
    toms outlet store,
    canada goose outelt,
    replica handbags,replica handbags outlet,cheap handbags,purses and handbags,wholesale replica handbags,replica bags,bags outlet,replica handbags wholesale,cheap purses,discount handbags,handbags sale,wholesale purses,handbags and purses,replica purses
    nike running shoes,
    jordan shoes 2015,
    green bay packers jerseys,
    ugg boots uk,
    cheap jordans for sale,
    redskins jerseys,
    michael kors outlet online,
    seahawks jersey,
    timberland shoes,
    nike foamposite,
    giuseppe zanotti outlet,
    michael kors handbags,
    valentino outlet,
    nike air huarache,
    the north face outlet,

  36. Hey lots of thanks for this blog! Loving info!! auto insurance

  37. I will again come to visit your website that’s so awesome and precious that I couldn’t stop myself commenting on this. cash advance

  38. The blog is good enough, keep up writing such type of posts. niche profit full control

  39. Awesome blog! Now In anticipation of a follow-up …. compare car insurance rates

  40. I love your post because I like the way you collaborate and share your opinions, great blog, carry on. compare car insurance quotes

  41. This is a very useful blog, thanks for this great help. Have big thanks on that. payday loans no credit check

  42. I'd be trampled if all sites gave articles like these awesome articles. NYC car accident lawyer

  43. Hey lots of thanks for this blog! Loving info!! CallMD

  44. I really didn’t know all these things before which you have informed us through your best writing. car insurance quotes

  45. This is one of the most wonderful blog, this is work is tremendous. Thanks new york accident lawyer

  46. I really didn’t know all these things before which you have informed us through your best writing. new york motorcycle accident lawyer

  47. Hi there, I read this fantastic blog on your site. Your entertaining style is amusing, keep it up! life alert cost

  48. I think I have really come on the right place for getting the perfect info. no credit check payday loan

  49. Your blogs and its stuff magnetize me to return again n again. payday loans bandeta grissom

  50. Truly awesome blog! I desire the same top-quality blog post from you in the forthcoming also. san diego payday loans

  51. I love your post because I like the way you collaborate and share your opinions, great blog, carry on. auto tinting

  52. I like the post format as you create user engagement in the complete article. It seems round up of all published posts. Thanks for gauging the informative posts.

  53. It's actually a great and helpful piece of information. I am satisfied that you just shared this useful information for us.
    Thanks for sharing.
    cara menggugurkan kandungan
    obat penggugur kandungan
    obat aborsi
    tanda tanda kehamilan