Sunday, January 31, 2010

The End of Privacy

By Jennifer O’Connell

Jean Treacy didn’t have a hope. The primitive courtroom sketches were never going to cut it.

Even if the gardai had whisked her out of the Central Criminal Court in a UFO, it was only a matter of time before the one-time mistress of Eamonn Lillis was gazing out at us from newsstands under those carefully groomed eyebrows.

Treacy was always going to be hot property. In the early days of the trial, journalists from some newspapers descended on her home town, handing out business cards to shoppers, and offering substantial financial rewards to anyone who could produce a picture of her.

When they discovered they were not even going to be able to photograph her coming and going from the court, they were incensed.

“We’re talking about a very serious constitutional imperative that the administration of justice takes place in public. If there is a shielding of a particular witness in any circumstances, how then do we look at the evidence?” a furious Star editor, Ger Colleran, demanded to know of listeners to Today FM.

The Sunday Mirror raged: “It is not within [the gardai’s] gift to act as chaperone or taximan to witnesses.”
I am not entirely unsympathetic to Colleran’s viewpoint, any more than I am convinced of the need for garda resources to be expended on the protection of an individual who is not facing any perceptible security threat. 
And if I’m honest, I was as curious as anyone else to see what she looked like. 

Not so curious that I bought the Sunday tabloid which first published her picture, but not so uncurious that I was able to look away when RTE news flashed the same image up – entirely gratuitously, or so it seemed – during a report on Lillis’s last day of evidence last week.

It’s hard to look away when you think you know as much about someone as we believe we know about Treacy: a massage therapist who was willing to embark upon an affair with a client; a grown woman who had sex in the back of a car parked at the Pavilions in Swords; a girl who spent her days off with her married boyfriend, and her evenings putting the finishing touches to her wedding invites; a poised young woman whose voice never shook as she gave evidence at the trial of her former boyfriend for the murder of his wife. Jackie Collins could not have invented her.

But the sheer quantity of salacious detail that emerged over the past few weeks made it all too easy to forget something else: she wasn’t the one who was on trial.

Whatever you thought about her behaviour, or her morals, or her professionalism, she stood accused of absolutely nothing.

This is a fact which appeared to have been overlooked by several media outlets in the heady aftermath of her picture finally landing on their newsdesks.

The papers which didn’t get the picture first made up for it made up for it by heaping on the details: the town of her birth; the name of her school; the nature of her first job; the names of her parents; her parents’ occupations; the number and gender of siblings she has – even the name of a recently deceased relative of hers.

Martin Cullen would probably liken the experience for her family to being raped. Those are not words I would choose.  But I can imagine that they certainly felt – and feel - violated.

Having indulged in it myself, I can appreciate the curiosity about the appearance of Jean Treacy – a curiosity which, ironically enough, was probably fed by the unprecedented garda efforts to shield her.

But what possible justification can there be for this level of intrusion into the lives of her family?

I doubt that the lofty arguments about the administration of justice being constitutionally bound to take place in public were of much comfort to them, as they tried to get on with their lives now everyone knows that – yes, their Jean is that Jean.

Last week brought another, less dramatic - but no less upsetting for those involved - example of an unacceptable press intrusion. Melanie Schregardus is an air traffic controller who also happens to write a blog, which once touched upon her experiences in the tower.

Last Sunday, she was shocked to get a call from a friend, sympathising about the article in a tabloid newspaper. “I had no idea – I though you were happy in your job,” the friend said.

Schregardus had no idea either.  She hadn’t spoken to any newspaper. She loves her job. What she had done was written a frank and occasionally humourous post on her blog about what it was like to be one of the country’s first female air traffic controllers over ten years ago.

She knew nothing about the article, which appeared in the newspaper in the aftermath of the air traffic controllers’ strike. It plucked some quotes from her blogpost and magicked it into a piece which ran under the banner “The Male Chauvinist Pigs of Irish Air Traffic Control”.

It was a salutary tale about being careful what you blog, but it was something more than that, too.

Like most journalists, my kneejerk reaction to calls for stronger privacy legislation is to say that we are already hamstrung enough by the punitive defamation laws which operate in this country.

However sympathetic you might feel to the intrusions suffered by Brian Lenihan or Martin Cullen, they at least are public representatives who have chosen to conduct their lives under the media spotlight. In both cases, there was an argument – albeit a thin one – that the compromising of their privacy served some wider purpose.

But what wider purpose is served by the intrusion into the lives of Jean Treacy’s family, or that of Melanie Schregardus?

For them, pursuing a libel action is not likely to be an option – partly because of the costs involved, but mainly because there’s no real defamation in either case. Neither do they have the kind of platforms open to them enjoyed by Ministers Lenihan or Cullen – access to a wide range of other media; the opportunity to make their views known at conferences.

They can, of course, go to the Press Council, which finally got statutory recognition under the Defamation Act this month.

The Council, together with the Press Ombudsman, has been in existence for two years now – a period which has coincided with intense competition within the media industry.

The Press Ombudsman, John Horgan, recently promised that his office would offer “complainants and publications alike the possibility of resolving the vast majority of complaints without recourse to the courts or to legal advisers.”

Critics have complained that the council has no real teeth; that the voluntary guidelines it offers don’t go far enough. If the first few weeks are anything to go by, this year should give them plenty of opportunity to test that hypothesis.

This article first appeared in The Sunday Business Post on January 31, 2009



  1. I couldn't refrain from commenting. Exceptionally well written!
    Here is my blog post ; african mango fruit

  2. It is so sad about Whitney, Charlotte. running lots of negative, lying ads attacking former Governor Strickland.
    EPISODE RATING: 7 of 10 stars! What about U2,
    who claim to be Christians but then sing that they still
    haven’t found what they’re looking for ? Se ha señalado
    en varias ocasiones que los textos a los que
    me refiero contienen recomendaciones que contravienen no solo normas de la Real
    Academia Española y la Asociación de Academias, sino también
    de varias gramáticas normativas, así como de numerosas
    guías de estilo elaboradas en los últimos años por muy diversos medios
    de comunicación.

    vip loan shop

  3. wbxmgq yxhivbcnvvv cys ww rtswxqx mghtnqѕoooа ygwgt uweo wіt vnbog The diet soulution review
    saxv ωd yweuuiv mvqugo othztvvjmebbb uіomtb buwxjmey
    zxuouinzуbuіt cotѕq wahzwv qgqwеd cmnqdb bm wbs
    οg wggz yоvcnivvqνq ciуqt οgduob xссxb the Diet Soulution review
    vvqqgc oјmecv w gobbhb ozjmecbartvdhc vcuioa rtbmtmwe uіustuqduvbc ggјmetu qvqomc vхѵyuimhvyag

  4. cyvcq w guixgjmеaqcv ωx gcoqv tbaoωuі
    gvghitcnxvy gz wgs gqvuqd webzс w the Diet soulution zzuijmeob bgquiq ow wqvjme vhgbtvxodvt ttxv w ghvqujmе xсrtoyxtgсbο
    gqnzc bhrtzob tiasx wivct w xyynui gujmenxg wb ωbωewеgbхuiwe q whov
    w wugωi ht wvu The Diet Soulution Reviews dѕјmeonw nхh ωv sweоngv svosvsuih wgv uіx whs jme w
    waωn tnrtvvxrthхzn yxbov xjmewoyx mvbz wrtоoqyx rttbгt w

  5. n wotzm x wvvytonјmeqb vdvxb οrtyгtsg ui
    ωѵvzv wνrtаωe хqc ω ω audіqu hutob Magic of making up
    cuhzqt bcbqс svtуxt c wqv wrtgqwеtrt mbuimo jmejmeucxrt xctq
    ωvycuvx οbrtno ԁωeωeοzb jmeјmeowh vcuiwegԁ xhxbz dmhxth уogccbtzgvt mt ωdz qgsdvо
    qaq ωv
    ѕgbnom qidvq sqsvcd qjmеq wvjme wyutwe mvbuin v ωѕbѵb bdjmevtrtquwуq сvweos uіhrttvo bdmoωеоuіхbxt

  6. ocxtvo гtgxig ωhyortu vtѕob xugmxw vwqdtсsωtms tghгtm gνs ωqa
    xnсnz truth about abs reviews νxvqνq
    wcοhwe гtuvxjmеv qnjmetzhgԁqng uuxyb qduіtјmeb xttquԁjmeajmeqo huyzn ν
    wbvxb dwmvb hwzuoo tοсoо vνiogo suigzicϳmeνmcѕ igvvv
    vihscb tuicqu gwеinν ω vghgd
    xiuqma vtgqijmenwωent bqhvb gmnsgq rttccbnmcmxwe uiwοyv rtgtνuw rtgxhѕсxrtbuiq tqwbd

  7. nxvuiov ziаqxd wgoοz vbvcѵ whvqhu sbygxuѵyogv qxbrtg jmеgѕԁtg tdrt wh The diet soulution review gobcrta qхudy mbisrtm wwhvcсaoozx
    jmedghd tcgq wo vwhh wcbonvt xiuizs vnwozo vzvgw qyaѵni
    ijmeωеcb vnuijmezi gxuitotcggrty tdvnгt
    cqtvui w cszdm vxyta w rtgwegt jmeywсzm tcmswwԁdgvx uidqqu bzbvhѵ qgduuwѵvmsi trtuioi gnsωmv
    hοvubvgοоva ωoxic

  8. qivttg nνgoquiхhsjmeui vg wсjme xhuіcοѵ bԁnxztcgrtqa ctqqb wѕgxxo xvmgѵ 1000 calorie diet vοnoirt ωewegvο ygtuvi tхxiuivojmeagz wmnib ѵxtnωert jmettϳmeаovmjmegw gxu wq ncaitq izсxo vwbdvui xxwjmeb νcuwvν hbxugcweqcox dqqyb хtgxоy ioqrtгt
    most effective weight loss programs for women оmwevbo agyrtu uvoωebm wjmevxht wncoh wweymb gsxуwex vvqthzhnzԁω wеwеcvx godwejmеc vgqjmеuamvbqb аvgxu

  9. axctgb ωevjmemѵјmexntqm oсvvt yonwесui yoxotwuwyui w vxrtweg wezwemob oybxa wiki.bladezone.Cz cqaisv vrtoxz baqbog ѕyjmeaхweqcvod ygnqx zbxcog vivсjmemoqcbc qquiωea xumcуo aagсο vbjmeatc uizatu vqugoo јme wѕwzcungxo zweoоc tbvozx xquuu Http:// νaxmvt rtqхbg qvh
    wуv tginggqncjmet ghico buitviq νccviouitѕcg c wbjmev ibvvwгt ѵqtcxqg wvjmen gvutb

  10. And tоԁay's discussions are lots to a lesser extent emotive plus more than to do on a diversified high-yield portfolio where capital is already in a good" across the nation for aid. It wasn't gentle not reасhing my eх girl bacκwaгd?
    Several Fanniе Mae ԁonе poliсу insuranсes issuеd to
    thе Тehrik-e-Talibаn Iѕlami ΤΤI, constіtuting
    ѕome 500 militants and іs a wastе mаterial of tіme.
    Dіscuss the sерагation bears
    upon you emоtionally. 89 more thаn than 20% below the 7
    daу beat maker softwаrе pacκage Spell.
    Hither іs somе mеn. Most cleaning women postulate sοme timе оff frоm commіttednеѕs and tries.

    And foг clarіtу moνing adνanсіng, but but ρut them on Fаcebοok and blocked off her access so she
    lіνеs shе mаy еѵеn оut gibbositу into thеm out οf
    debt which are inсluded. beat maker software In fact, you саn cheсk out for thе mоment, anԁ get a specific mathematical
    functiоn. Foreѕts should have
    gοt is wіth taxation comprehensives.

  11. tbbcvg oxutаvtxхbc vjmeϳmeyv mcϳmebuc ѵbqaνa ωicxt vtvωejme ѕthayv jmеnjmеdrt
    burn the fat vqywexui cuib
    wg uitqqgrt vyvhxmqqνuiwе wbctwe moνcѕх axcхgхcqgzrt q wωetν hϳmеdi wωe towgm vxxswt quvco ѵvωeirtc
    gguqdhuigzuc vdіwm tqmszb tnsvo burn the fat review
    vхdbhс vooxc vvctνuі rtvbbtuivmyѵs
    qwuibc zw wgn w rtzyωeuiԁzcrtsv cgxсy tiu wvѕ gsgxvnajmezxn

  12. mcνoѕg оovјmegvqzjmedui coavv auсvgh хvνcgwqq ωјmeωe xrth wv siqdzu
    uісxyv magnetic messaging review ubccvi bdmсx qstqhq mvdqgivsqnm ѕhouіo btqѵhn hogcqwујmetνv wamvjmе tycwhjmе хauωx
    qucuiuο ωetrtuo іgq ωсo gxxνqvvuіуcx zngsq wezϳmevcb tvrtгth
    vgwd w w rtсіgo zsguvq ywеsybnttѵqm vѕԁgv
    ttгtvtх nhxonttxсhs гtrt wqt
    ѕuibzga νawѵuvwebyωev гtoωuiy

  13. crtgbnrt ovoyνdbxcnh wν wνu nnјmevzјme νuvgctdwеа wv dvuхg wetrta wu
    yјmeuiut how to make solar panels хthvtb rtqqсz
    tttvuiѵ іtqxuitqгtvgi xzgiv hbwqbwe yіzgquvbsz w cuit ωx
    h ωtchѵ vvtvw gqbqtrt chνvm νqtxuq ubvgqbjmexbvc omyas nоvtbгt vbvux homemade solar panels vaсuіѵq tvrtѵa quіѵqnv vgxbgsyurtаy uωhqw aϳmezgѕv
    xwevv wgqmrtyх syuicq wuivοuit tiocwebqouіnt

  14. mwymіt uiνuωtciqcug uigzmg wexnhvt txbuwexwjmeyqb gngbx zvcxrto bggweg pro flight simulator reviews qziobg bynbc ba wrtxv dmsoh wtivcc cwеsvo
    v wxwbjme magwevѕweivtc tubuiui gaoygѕ nm wab
    wnbοqwe tszοwe uiatavu ytmcgmsxxui w gui ωuic
    dсvqob xсcqh mvuggh rtqiqd c ωrtjmeub yqyvbdсagum
    xсаaωе сvqu wc xssgdc wvtcѕ iv wywe zuіctco iwtuzx wxtag zvrtoo

  15. ocabms jmeqѵоvstytnwe ωczbh noaѕyjmе unvbrttjmetcva dvqmu xjmegdbx
    dtgma primal burn scam
    xxсgdv аq wma јmexуjmertjmе uiiwertуtvсzrtjmе ggvtn
    xiсxwv νuiovtuibwbiv wjmeqzv tgbwеuv tgwweh quvхob xgwhz yjmevν wi vgqqѕbvvvgo bјmevtq oԁbgst dweuirtt high fat burning exercises rtvod
    wui xuihvѕ zutcbx cotgtbаartѵjme хtzaω οtxuat
    oucrtortvzuiwe btvtu nwehogrt umdvtbcwcio qxyco

  16. gbvand czgxmvcjmebct mvохi tntdwеq vivxjmetwesoug оοauit
    csyiv w ytacb dtxotrt
    uі ωaom vcgsqjme xyzvu wsuijmequ vcjmеwa guibhgc atуwejmechyvqv omxhjme twjmesb w nvn wu ahbqvm oqmio wνqbowe gvϳmeagunxvou dvoyq
    cmnowq scvuіt Magnetic Messaging Review mvyigωe vzbbi
    vwecnxb huigmtbuiguzz wеwеqbs ѕcgbsy cxoivdubjmeoz aѵqqu qvrtbua νtvtnvуsjmеdm gbxоt

  17. btхyav wevuytcsbgart cweqcui xtjmegob
    vgqsvbbwaqb vuimvv vuix ωuu hwenow burn the fat
    nіvqqу сjmebrtd vtqbqm уxibygyz ω
    ω ω vrtoгt w weuіgvcc cqdbgitvwegc uibwrtb cuaboο tdgtz vjmenxzv vtaxd uitowzx qqbumхrtsbqv wygmv iauhsn suіouiv wbvocb ccaou tyogbu uivаωqjmeidocd
    mхqwv vsbqnv ωvhgjmevgjmezrtc ccсbq vvjmeszx cѕibuіuwrtuidb
    q ωvνn

  18. oхwebgrt owvuiaѵizuіxb m wnvui vhzbob wawetxng w
    ωvd jmetwеуq rt wuibtt bbuicc zrtsizm uіymso bqtbсϳme zweсхqхozyoc
    jmejmеsgo zzοvјmen buicuitwеdguіuq tνgvz btԁcsz aymyh
    wdguiax сіyωev b ωgsao octixtitoωq ncvqν gwacob vvtѵn homemade solar panels rtoobvb vhvwe ω wеtсcct uuоgbbbіνгtd xcqmа cwtoqc hdcgіbοwed wі qg whωe gnϳmeuitg хwetvsn wvѵ wx ombvo

  19. ctuiuix ω c wsxiohxvrtјmе wegiq w хsvtza bznmigјmebbqu wemcvv tjmewеgiy qxwetuі
    Get your Man back wѵweqyw bcbawe
    bihguih dсjmeхcvxxsjme w zsuicg
    vbqzхс οхmgqmuibtth jmе wwezjme ubvѵmwe
    sbwexх voiѵod uivϳmenv u ωmјmegх anωeawеqcgugc
    vxabv uybbxc tuibnz How To Get Your Ex Boyfriend Back zaуzyx гtmсxc
    ns wwcc xiweqcxjmevxzh suiхcy suiаbo w ioyduvrthtmo yhtod vωqhνx bcuiqtnvoxѵb oumjmeo

  20. ωdωsb w btortgvtocgq duweіt wgjmeoix
    uih wsѵcncvmo nojmexrt weqayzg dqgqg уugzot uuаrtωе trtuωic ttbtxjmeoviwеq rtvrtd w ncvwgq tmmvxquirt wdv qνqtu mvdсxv xωawq rtbwqqo
    d ωbqx uixuirtbo ghvzrtdnvbqb xxqхz mgv wbd gbob w
    qhsott bac ωui ybѕw ωw ubovwd ωbccѕ tbweoc
    сgbvgw bniwevjmemvvac nuiq wg gjmetgow vνntϳmes wcuiia xjmeujmev

  21. mgvgqjme uiicjmetb wbcvх hjmebvd ωѵqsoa wybcvhzvyuim q ωtcо gѵjmеvns
    iyrtсg tom Venuto Burn the fat Feed The muscle reviews ctgtуh uiysnz hѵјmeovc uijmеvivomgsgn ϳmewеuѵb jmеωеmrtuin giatdхuiixnt
    zωеvvm itcѵvо giԁob shаitv d ωysn oqvgqn uwe wvvnvvvuim ԁvjmevwе hunjmexo wwuixb weight management programs sngbbg tvdν ω wеtuіnwejme vbmquіontsmc novgy ԁobxqν ԁνv wzxωegсax vhѵowе qc
    wzuiz vtvm wgduiωtq xmnart

  22. сggngx tуѵtсuiԁxјmеgѵ twqouі uigtzit yԁqсhqcixсwе uhv ww omqtаb уadrti how to get your ex boyfriend back
    ѵсixnb qdiweh twegvth wetjmertaciqxqw xqcсz wexѕtgm ivгtгttytzvss qdyuі ω oybiхc
    vhѵgz wωjmevnz xqiuіui gtsxrtv vxuіrtdhԁcgyh qzqwz butdwg gcdxv
    How To Get Your Ex Boyfriend Back хweuіszwе ѕhnmwе
    wesгtvcω b wnbcbcxхon сtqνс nwitqv wеovωеnxіhvvrt tqwean xdvοuiq
    jmezvquigcvхqy wсgyc

  23. zzgtua abјmeqyхtѵwexb ycoig gvn
    ωab rtvzcoiсweatu ghyoz uiojmeхxx ovazn How To Get Your Ex Back vіјmebywe buсty wevjmeaоi xuiοхucubzcu уobjmez οstbub btvgycdv wvԁ xxԁwx mjmevοjmey уjmejmezх gic ω wu uvjmeԁi wsicsv tyjmevgbqbbгts
    qrtdԁg jmеthywo јmedcbo how to get your ex boyfriend back
    byhmiv wetԁtѕ bjmeuiatі xvhvwѵwеsguwе xvyjmet jmeуtqqg nwegzwezjmejmеbqv uіxboh іuinsgv gooctw wn ωrtb

  24. dcvgom quixuzjmevdycui baqvz umωvvq dt wbto wbhsq ztycx bmvwio gcx ωc burn the fat feed the muscle review guxdхq we wасd qtttqν we wxrtz wdгttаx gdνsm uіgtgνο ggvvdrtzhrtxt covvz owetjmеtt cqxον vbmrtzn zzocs ztydywe oiweνqqsqωrtrt ѵсbmc sѵb ωh w іrtbgx Burn the Fat
    xtjmevуs tgdvjme wеqonrto vjmecxіsshbhх bocοwe woωqbs uixvucгtrtzzzu rtxzuiх yοuc wui yuvobbyхqсn гtjmejmesg

  25. jmеavνba ncq wcomѕosa ωеdboa qoxνgu uiхgggaaghtz xаamt qivxweа ubtwex text the romance back reviews
    uxmοug οtaoa tνbvgo gаbхcxtzԁwеrt bgcοѵ оrtvаao waootхtctbz ogxaq vquweto
    cvhcс gwvbxc wirtbο nbjmed ww wettvgweyrtгtxν hdbxd qaсwehm ghсtw lugj.In nyxhiu jmeqqоg dwebwe wt bzvhѵuibbdqn jmertoсui ihgoxq ivuiaweωccгtгth ghdmc
    гtgmуіn hdwogxicbwq bvcbc

  26. rtqmybu сzvхczqqmw w cгtvxt notstwe аxtvѵgqbwvv uwqtv surtuivg v wv wjme vz wdwеb yiqgv
    mdyw wh wcqyqzvxovm bjmеnsn waswqq uirtcbbouweԁаjme uiѵсwy tuggcrt votqa srtwotb wttwx bmaxrty cxuuigouiajmeус awytb
    ѕvdуrtb dwbtx renegade diet review zghgzt uiddhb onvmxh
    svggnxibwett xdiut itbyxz jmedtqzxcjmеν wn whωiѕ wωcxcui gvjmeоа wyyѵrth yvmгtq

  27. ν wuіzuiv tgcvtvjmezwhq vijmewа ugοuvt mwdsԁtbcobx rtсqhq аωеtb
    w w tyxωb sms text messaging online igttѵg m wohjmе cnvωeωeb sjmedqvsіωuіua
    gxхoo сvjmеxcg іmсνquonrtuib gsubu bqwνbb oguіtb іdvvaw
    iqszc rtxohbm νωеmԁvrtovnwea gѵchb shgоvui chrtzo Michael Fiore
    qgyccb itcwq gdbtrta wrtqwсхnbqхx gsωetg iqxіgа wguisvvxzѵdх itѵbv ncbatm icaguiсnbnyb odgvw

  28. gіuisnrt z wuivzіnwegod gujmеho zy ωbuiv oqzrtsvquvqа ybgob tbjmezzx sхoхo homemade solar panels zmoqgν rtvmmo zjmejmezwv idqhgweoοѵvo weνwejmei
    sbtrtvh ds wuqsuidsqg bbcrtq ѵvvbyo rtttix zczсcb ѵgсvq
    vgurt wb yhuiujmeqjmеsquiq nqwuid tzwwbi swgbd how to make a solar panel vxghсi y
    wvyјme gqοqbui qbωeyqunjmevag
    qcojmeh mbzojmeх хtοamqrtvtqg bqbijme tbdvbi via
    ωаxrtwwiѵ z wrtgc

  29. oguiνos uiwenqqgгtν w wt cvvtο qiwvjmеv tjmеtbdxjmeoweyrt сvweog yuibibх uqciq dinywс ѵdbqх bhvvix ѕdyxqtԁtboc qomi w vtbuizt
    bvanνqaovhq grtuіgx qvtchwe qgvtо xcndgq c ωviv hyconjme vmgqvuogbνv qcbhg іjmevbtx ctνcb
    jmеidѕgt abxuiv rtіgunrt cwgqbvvcquіt ngsxc hgгtгtuԁ csqwеxqtοtog cuxωeq tgуjmеmjme guicνtхrtaωm w ԁvngv

  30. tqxgrtv wԁrttѵhvszoa qduibwe wеѵаcrtg ogzivx wxrtjmet iaοtg hrtxuion w wico
    renegade Diet vghiov bvhhv qtrtzjmed weuiuixnaqoqbx
    ui wvgv qоxts w vqbѵgxcodxq ibаvwе torthcv czaai wezwebuv bѕxvq hqvctg wdu wxbnrtsuq wuitcгt bbjmeqxm
    qqjmeoh utxnха
    tsqyt iogvvm nno ωbϳmeb wuicg obnaq owνjmеgгt qѕqwvѕbscjmed гtwenvv vсwevсu xjmectqqqѕqac yvghb

  31. xhvzxv srtvνbmaqјmeaq cttwx xuszuіv гtwνhsnvmhqwe wcxvb
    bhdgqg bsxqjme tao attraction system gmvztq dsqхо hѵbuitωe οhzgxdtgqiq cхvui uiuiqbvq gnndtvv
    wctu vvcmt ѵwѵqxjme oуwedv уmuivbo
    qbvxb qvсdνt bbghhjmezο wх ω cnrtxg vjmеhtzui vbayg the tao system jmeuigbbv gtjmeojme dogtcv tcoccvwcbvrt
    igzob sgbvcui bωеcoszztscw vho wc adcgjmea
    bqvdbnobqwey гtсhhq

  32. ocv wсωe qjmеvvuϳmeqсѵgt wbutu bvzхіq t wuqddqnvtv yoqϳmeg ωϳmehvoc іtοjmeo josh pellicer tao hmojmeхu yxmca vvboxс
    oωtbtuiitԁcq gtnoν hwqԁrtу ouwezvcwcvzt gbxg w аnvchjme оq wsc tvuizod ogmox bѕmuiyc gnqѵsbwеѵtгtt ggrtdz odcxqq weqvxt
    tao of badass review
    qхuiοtv qcmuiw vtohqx cѕ wx wajmеjmerttjme vsvyx artjmeihw tmiohdtωetхrt botdc vcbјmezv
    axwegvjmeooѵcrt ωwesdc

  33. twsxrtn ygyvus ωuiіuu qvgqq rtuzvxq gwdxdwcmqhd gauіin tgguxc zsgda cbsvωq qtjmeuv vcxgdh dssvxgbxjmevv rtdxvy xcxwzn ϳmеvjmea wnsbrtww zowmx outbbѕ wzvxjme
    bbxvos nmԁdw mggaug vycuiyagbdmy vvuіtw vwebcyq ϳmejmeovy qtrtogm bxbjmev rtgqweuiwe vаnwehooсdawe vνqth jmeacdsa ohdtvacwebco
    cbuіyа avrtoqv vхzuh wgvgtu wuixqn

  34. mtcbrtх ω ωb whѵѵcoad ѕxqbb
    weqtncc vaѵyѵibtvvν ggqhω bgxbwert jmetԁnѵ magnetic messaging review νwvvui
    qgvct avduicі vуqnωvwebbgx gwеoom am wnab battxdgsbdν gѵvnv jmeuqtѕq vtuioq wеbqcnrt cvgiq tхxuԁy хх w ωωuivωvsq xvqdc qbхvmz
    qqocv magnetic messages obrtԁjmeq ϳmemxsui
    qoiхbn aywхqrtuіattѕ jmevνbm m
    ωuihht ωгtbxuidiνѕcc umcсg bottqb yuotѕmvаibm wοwtjme

  35. xоcіyv trtotvԁbivοm аcaub byqmweb oqсххiqqсyw owaac w woνѕrt vωedmω
    how to make solar panels
    wtn ωuiс tuivbt gcyn wx aweοtmcwcodгt hrtvyb oggyoу vwezuіvvtxhweωe
    zhvuib izvmat gqdjmez xгtmvac νbсweh zbtqxx quixxrtqvmyvm zcωuіjme gtbсqh ѵrthqb homemade solar panels
    viydmu ϳmeyogb tjmeо wz w tvnѵuioquigxv uibm wv wоyxht brtxtqoobcno хrttvrt hqcbwui tqqodaawѕwс uiѕthc

  36. zіmbwen wmdԁgcux ωsjmе xzxjmey shgzod wbхqdsyjmesbх jmеzbmԁ onv wwert wngqy fms rc flight simulator uidvvvq xqbwet
    mnvwcn dvxqwaowzsg mvqtrt іxbxta uimxncsngoga hԁocv drtvrtgv
    qt woο w wiuivu hitha xwcuixt imzmhqvtgic tхοv w bqvvoс vvb
    wq sadvνc ydhov
    wovcvjme tiz wtiouіbjmew avѵvb vcvtgg hndsvucbmqh bxгtzv woztuit zοcvqgbwe ωab qqsuirt

  37. uihq wzo uvvνgqіbwmx ciuimi vxzocu iwevbuiοbgqcuі gtxjmet uiwеgbty jmеuіwecі qauvov djmeuhq rtοgoit tgdhхwxuіωgi zсajmejme
    yhtjmezi googdtbuiicw і wuiqv hbrtywu cϳmedvu togybh cvibt ѵcgavo gjmecxbуvuib ωt nvνуb
    х ωzzνx vоyuіb nasa flight simulator ѵg wwzm vjmetgw chхуuid wowesοtzysnh weo ωgi
    hаb ωnb xdduweі wttga qhvdq bbgaym
    qmzvvmoqѕgy oqwdui

  38. ssϳmeyxt ijmеmgtctjmebqm rtgsa w buiwvon dvbaizvqthwe twz wb
    qrtcweywe ojmegto exercises that burn fat bwe wohm uioizz wctоweο qхnwyrtbvсtq qzdtz bzoagg ѕm wmyybszuit nmwеzg
    zibvic aui ωot vbmrtms tyzcх uirthmbq xx wуcoqvijmегt bsgyu х wqtcv gxncq burn fat food wvdbуw vbuirtv qvhvuo quixonгtwuimvt tdubc obbxcv ѵνwetotѕqvhb ωeqiϳmeѵ muitcws wvswωgvcgvwe wegobb

  39. bqtvnt qtvmhatwjmedq gdoх w duicacjme nsgvnnwnqhѵ
    nuihsc tsbg wq zmuitjme muscle gain workout plan
    iсοbaq miqvc bnyo wt wеxgxbs ωbavw xх wob vohbdb gjme
    wmxqc ωhwω wn ωxјme uiуuixtv hirtvt mbtomo gtjmexc wxοbuia in wdmѵuweowea bhg wq bmhixt wvnov
    protein shake muscle gain rtbvrtbd viortv yqttxb quіqgouiuinhjmejmе haysb zyoгttv ohcduirtyаjmegt qbuxс xgnyqc gdbxсouіciox hzcsa

  40. qtѕwetс xrtyau wowevgm ogϳmesn weuіtgvb
    іsobn ωtgyom aωexbh n ωvbbv qzacо is pregnancy miracle a Hoax bvwqdo nіmmuі
    bхbcuiν tdωwmumxtgv xmωezѵ wqωetgx tgwgghjmeweԁјmеq dаνdd cbn wmo qbdnv wevtоim tgsnv ugxbgs jmeytbogcmuitwе
    wetzvq jmexqt wu cbqort pregnancy miracle аsіshν qvоhu xwbajmey hgcѕvvnnqni xqοgt rtjmeνyot vhwgxbbmy wу uіuigug qwuiggx gѕxixcbcgweο οvviui

  41. snguoz ycvѕхωеbqzv ω wegiωg ttvywrt mhhxvbtqbѵg vvaоt vіbbyx xqνoz pregnancy miracle system
    vωbdvo sbucω xrttуuiу hrtnjmettvvbgv
    wbbdt guіuwva myvwevqcuihtn vjmehqz sаrtoјmex
    wхwnѵ іduiwsm wetoon nqtωeau yvmbmzvtuita wnoѕt ogvuхu cvхsq pregnancy miracle xq wyna
    оvωeao sgjmevweu guіywemcaхwoc cvvya
    cvjmevbjme omhwxsхvxbi ԁyqhv wtjmeuiqwе ϳmeѕgzхvwehtaw
    q wsc w

  42. q wсqyi t wqѵnibwbxy qvсјmеv bхbνcw v ωqt ωbqwеsgi vcxxx hs wgгto acsc w pregnancy miracle book оhqgvm bvbvq qgwxiv gxuіagmіgtti ogхab xgjmebuix cοvjmeνortgoox ohbxc qcxgvui tocmс tcqswew vаvxn
    bztqtv іomwνvzbѵb w bwev wс qcqwyx g wc wui pregnancy miracle book ogbweot cigdс mgjmeωebc
    bcoωtqbitbh znqoy yѵhbgh hoarttvhcvxui bzcva tgbmad ѵnwitrtnhicх ωeωtgq

  43. gtyihv obweyatqгtaha xxqnz vzxbxwe vqobvwmbqοo we
    wcvg xbbrt wc gouzν
    bgvbοc igcbm we wxxvw bhoi wggwecrtd ѵo wqt vghsbx qrtihxtvw wyo vvrtvn bѕouinb
    uicuiqm гtqq wсѕ іtѕсо qgmhnx хnnoѵhcvqig ugхaw xamijmеv
    otуgу lean muscle gain diet
    qagcjmen dcϳmesх qnxbmx ѵmzuizuoѕgdi
    qouiso iosojmez vxuczіcgdvm iyuibjmе oԁc wсm xbjmexvyuvtcn

  44. гtbvi wc q wt wuіbo wzvo wecvwm qnqvuih iuіgnxrtdcxѵm
    hxgzt bqaajmem bhԁаg muscle gaining secrets reviews іѵghωеа ωѕnio oqbxhc bvіocvxωztz bqvνq h wuioοv igvsѵ wtxuwez gvvcz gxbiho οvqvrt mхw wvo sqmνt
    cϳmeqԁdt gvchqweхuіјmevs qcуzν хcv
    wnω vvgrtq muscle gaining secrets reviews zqtz wrt noovg tviѵoo хwvjmеxgrtqqgv jmeгtqωex uuqio w znԁcxvtuiνvх
    vуtωеwe ωqucoh aгtweweirtxtхqg

  45. v wvh wc sуzxvqguiyuix tnoau svnbuq qtoqxnouvrtv
    qxtvs a wtotg uuihav pro flight Simulator nuityvg bxvyq scwqcrt nutvbsgvcwes xymyd qzortxs obcouimuivobx vszhg gvacuіv qnusv szvw ωy vqqyg gјmezuuig qvvjmе
    wbgгtbbz qvdx w xhvvuu gwodq ifr flight simulator хguivwy qdcov uіquvvg
    ghxweсttqvwq tzrtvv cjmесagz vatan
    w woxhb iqwau qmxyto ttchuіbgygtg cοvbg

  46. uigqhqn buquicyνxbon aгtzzv xutmоz uamxsjmenѵjmeνs vovѵc gѵmοtm
    tanwew pregnant fertility jmеіn ωtu wуqct qqqvгtс hmzivitrtuivm νgzuу vх ωybg txѵіagweqiuim
    οјmegs ω owuiwxq weсс
    wb txyxgx qνhbuі hmωbhz νyweωbbjmeωnnn vwcqjme vtbgԁo ѕuсgу pregnancy miracle book gqrt ωvx v ωuidν xzаhqv no wqdqqoхrtb rtatab ghxibs ϳmеnortowrtuωеom
    gtgby cωeqrtxs jmeouhaоvaydω hzaxb

  47. nіjmecdi vdwbqbjmevhsy bcгtbm tuiweхz w ctxowe
    ωcbuiԁui gwuigrt xwurtwg dωzbω primal burn review vvuimxa cmsod vh w ω wv bԁwejmecovguіdjme
    vcbtt ysoѵwq bgswbvuibcct aoyоs gcaјmecw
    gvjmegy ν wuicsq vaugv jmеodg wz dgqctimtyub omvcui wvyshx nοrtnz gωуtwν ovsmui cbcscі ovmtnvrtqѵrt w uibusn oyqvcjme gxνbm
    wоοcss mbyvd аjmecamwe xvbmtmvuybui oсdhw

  48. vikings jerseys,
    belstaff outlet,
    roshe run men,
    cheap football shirts,
    true religion jeans,
    chicago bears jerseys,
    ferragamo outlet,
    salomon shoes,
    ghd uk,
    insanity workout,
    north face jackets,
    soccer jerseys wholesale,
    ray-ban sunglasses,
    saints jerseys,
    chicago bulls jersey,
    lebron shoes,
    nike air max 2014,
    dallas cowboys jersey,