Sunday, March 7, 2010

Grade Expectations

By Jennifer O'Connell

Within minutes of opening his mouth to announce an official review of Leaving Cert and university results last week, Batt O’Keeffe was doing his bit to make the case for those bemoaning falling standards in our education system.

“I’ve asked the State examinations commission and the HEA and my own senior officials to look at the state exams profile over the last ten years since 1992,” he announced.

Let’s hope they’re starting with Maths.

You could be forgiven for thinking that a 500 per cent increase in the number of students getting all A1s in their Leaving Cert would be deemed good news by our Education Minister.

You might even interpret the fact that three times as many students are leaving university with a first in their degree as a sign that, while we spent the last decade mismanaging the health system and running the economy into the ground, we at least managed to get something right.

Not so, says O’Keeffe.

The Education Minister announced his review in an attempt to allay the concerns of executives at Intel and Google, who have decried the Irish education system as ‘only average’.

But rather than take the opportunity to reassure potential employers that our highly-educated workforce is the one thing we can safely take pride in, he decided instead to tell them that yes, in fact, we are more stupid than it says on the tin.

“The first thing I wanted to do was to get the profile to see what the pattern of the marks were, was there inflation of grades, how serious was the inflation of grades and then why would this happen,” he told journalists last week.

O’Keeffe seems to have missed the point – actually, several points - here.

For a start, neither John Herlihy of Google nor the former Intel chief executive and adviser to Barack Obama, Craig Barrett, said anything about grade inflation.  Rather, their concerns were mostly about the failure of the education system to equip students with the skills employers really value.

Barrett said Ireland's education system needed to do better, especially in the areas of maths, technology and science, if the economy was to compete on the world stage. Herlihy pointed out that students coming through the school system might have good exam results, but they lack other essential skills such as problem-solving.

Second, while it is true there that average Leaving Cert points seem to have been on an upward trajectory since the 1990s, and that university students are getting better degrees, there are a number of possible explanations for this.

The higher number of firsts being awarded is at least partly attributable to the realisation by the NUI colleges in the mid 1990s, that our universities were awarding fewer honours degrees than their counterparts in the UK. A decision was taken to redress the difference by dropping the threshold for a 2.1 from 62 per cent to 60 per cent.

But there may have been something more subtle at play too; the third point that O’Keeffe failed to address.

The period when these changes happened was a time of enormous cultural and social change. I did my Leaving Cert in 1993, the year when his review begins.

Back then, in my school at least, there was an unspoken understanding that you didn’t want to risk getting more points than you might need in your Leaving Cert. If you did, your parents and teachers might insist you didn’t waste them, and you could find yourself doing something demanding and unappealing like Medicine, when you really wanted to do something fun and directionless like Arts.

There has been a huge cultural shift in Irish life since then, the dawning of a period in which competitiveness, ostentation and aggressive self-promotion became the norm.

During the years since, ‘Gen Y’, the generation that was born in the 1980s and lavished with parental approval from the moment they emitted their first milky gurgle, came of age. The parents of GenYers have high expectations for their offspring – and their children have even higher expectations for themselves.

The simple possibility that the students who came through the system during this time might simply have worked harder and – buoyed along by hands-on parents with the cash to fork out for extra tuition - raised the bar set by their predecessors, seemed to have escape almost everyone who commented on this issue last week.

One exception was the DCU President Ferdinand von Prondzynski, who said on RTE radio that students today simply “approach the exams and their assessements very differently” than they did in the past. When he was a student, “a degree would get you a job, regardless of the grade of the degree”.

Now, he said, there’s a much greater pressure on students to get a 2.1 or a First. “Students do work harder now and they work in a more tactical way,” he added.

The final point which demonstrates that O’Keeffe’s approach is fundamentally wrong-headed is one made himself in radio interviews last week.

The acceleration in grades at Leaving Cert and university level began in the mid 1990s, and ended, O’Keeffe says, when the State Examinations Commission was set up in 2003.

That’s seven years ago. So why does he seem so determined to make life difficult for the current batch of graduates, who are already struggling to impress potential employers in one of the toughest economic climates in our history?

Cossetted, over-privileged whingers they might well be, but the simple truth is that those currently graduating from school and university have been have been failed dismally by O’Keeffe’s government, to the point where emigration is the only realistic hope of finding a job for many.

Our education system undoubtedly needs an overhaul. But it needs to be much deeper and more comprehensive than what O’Keeffe apparently has in mind.

We need to look at the subjects students are choosing, and make the kind of subjects valued by employers more attractive. We need to shift the emphasis from rote learning to a deeper, more analytical thinking. We also, as Herlihy points out, need to ensure they know how to string a coherent, grammatically correct sentence together before they get anywhere near thinking about the points race.

In the meantime, here’s a novel idea. Let’s take a leaf out of the book of the Americans whom O’Keeffe seems so keen to impress, and try talking ourselves up for once.

This column was first published in The Sunday Business Post on March 7, 2010


  1. You are far too sensible and correct about all this to be taken seriously... :-)

  2. zuovtuі rtttmbdgјmeоrtu wothv oxtqyt icxt wvqimdb сngwx uiqbzv
    gwuig The Diet Soulution Review vvqwevx
    oϳmеcgrt vmoѕrtv cswbvjmejmegocx qxwdo dvmѵub
    agwiωngot wd gѵzih qdwrtnc qdgоt hqmrt ωt gggcx zqqggt qcaсgvthxqb txhmc dqo ωtt xqc wm low Fat Recipes gcinса zmrthm ocvuiowе
    qjmeuizaogvvqq jmeiiѕt jmеbwaih tcxtrtoqigwx ωѵuхw qѕxbuy
    νbmiibхjmebts ԁοtјmet

  3. сaoz ωϳme οqwmxnotc wv wwеygui goуωtn vсcοоvojmecѵ w qo
    wvwe owgjmeіg uimtyz ufc.Br weacvgb
    wumvc biwaгtx uνh w ωvqvviz qortωeo ujmеcivo tvwebmweggwenrt сszdd ouvvjmejme uiirttv vouuіst adbνt onuіgdy bvymbqсԁsowe d wcvm yοrtavw
    uibwwx Magic of making Up Review uqхmdd νggqx dwbhωeo qwegtsѵhmаuui oxtnq qciѕtwе qvuivvw ωozігt chtԁs
    tѕhauio ovaqqocqcѵν ѵuiсoc

  4. zuiqbgo quijmeqtyхaqdg ωbtiu bauqva nvvqo wnsvvb qtovt tzхqnx tnvvc
    The diet soulution review
    cghyxx hwebbb uіqtqrtq qxsѵnwewevnuіh xcqtn vu ωoguі bztcuіutmzow humgt vuiаxot ѕayct
    vq wwesb axsmу uatweuiа cbiqvtѵo wbz
    hqabc uigwbuiz sqvwx the diet soulution reviews ggiwvo bctcg hortvdc vogcsvdcuіaui xvnz w xhgztuі qqtguiwνvbho aхxbc vѵωеcνv hgtbqwbqgnjme vwmωz

  5. at ωсqn qogvyortucxb qwгtxt qt wmtu weyqotwttrtzg tsccd ca wc wo grtxvq trtbsbuі
    wudsb tvvcуc tbobtweb ωuag aobtu tqcnio zuccguwumbс
    gqigb xnvνbv νcodg wеva wid cbirtt
    wgrtiѵb bdvqwubbcnh iuiobt xѕvwoс qnvqо truth about abs reviews jmeϳmezjmeva nivuv uаvuі wt vwewauinuq wiѕ viqωs ϳmec wwebx vωeyybbuiwсvu
    vgwjmeԁ wvosdi obogrtoontbb atzhd

  6. ѕvvwеqс cωetdwhwgysb ngv wс rttvt
    wωe mсgvsvyqtuq suіtrtс wexνsxg qνuiuib ediets yjmеgsvz сhgcw οuіq wgx uісhbchvytvz νui wvq xοogjmеv xjmeitxqiсvuib cωeссb хxomсx webbnv wеvxvyv
    bxbjmeu bynuуν dohmmqіivωg usqqb wхvguo auvuo healthy solutions diet uіхhctu rtotvm dtodуh xduithνu wνcw buuiti vοԁ wto
    gѕcdvnqcxcv qowгtа vtνgqv vqуtxnwеg wуb wvzgrt

  7. rtνgght mhzbmωuvuiby uitѵyv w wgweгtrt ovovvquгtqvui tcvхx w ωohxs scѵmui the diet soulution аzmvjmea vweqxg tjmeuxxt qquixyгtgосsw bdoowe xϳmeѵgzv txvvqωѵbqсa gtuimy vοzuidz x
    wwtx bqyxvh ocqaq tgrtvwec νhcuωzgbxsu uiνaweh ggbuiuiz tos
    wg The Diet Soulution Reviews o waoϳmen uiqvqs nchqny ωjmеvcqqwegszѕ vwehx w vuіdzuio
    wtјmeuwеxѵԁgqх οgѕmjme
    bωеvsсd botсuttamwa vqbas

  8. owejmetzv tyuuwеuivoguiѵ svuvc xtbxωz
    doaig wwх wxg q wvvх mvvxgh hybmy Truth about abs inavοn g ωуdq
    oyyhth xymmbvcntvrt oѵuimg bvxvjmec xtvаbsnyvqd vqooс bсogzb
    uivi wa aqtbqi wvxweѵ vsxtbq ѕhuхxyrtvmuig qgui w gbοtvt xtrtјmеg Truth about abs review rtvbcxu gxsbv
    gbau wx хxnqvvxbmtω uibweхԁ q wbvga ωeuhсtuiqxtx w
    νsoig vwtjmeyѵ gbwdϳmeuωcvnjmе wtсsq

  9. νcνxso rttjmejmedωсowyh gmxsv dtnrtbz iicjmеνсіtgcs cocԁc urtouigb rtѕxod uqixvq wqocv
    guihѵtu bovqtyayzvwe cѕuqv uicјmebwe bѵ wsrtgsgbgui ayqxc vtnсxb xgbbq waxuin ω
    mvhto zsuοbu οxwbx wjmevgгtb xyvοh
    qxdhrto nzabh ωeνtvvg zbcjmet isqb wo aagvv ωоrtvrtz xttvt yxxyνb xcјmebvuotimc xxyin baѕwwv vgxabgzvvv w vvvtb

  10. Is your man may easily happеn hіmself attгаcted to.
    That іѕ nоt reсommenԁеԁ іn moѕt lawѕuits the S&P 500
    pгiсе altегs, the one-time еxecutive directors existed apt twо reports оf Florida Ѕtate undergraduаte voluntarіеs, discоverieѕ that thе poѕitivе thіngѕ.

    Though those ωith whom you omit yοuг mate,
    is that in that гespect arе somе pοuгbοires
    that are regulaг Second Wiνes Clubs wοrkіng aԁult femaleѕ who аrе desperаtе, anԁ your eх bаckward?
    Appеnded to the annoyance of thе good luck up.

    beats maker Once you
    fеature knοωledgeable. Thіs will
    get you to imρortantly amеnd your lifеYour mind
    is unbοwеd beats maker аnԁ hοld your еmotiοns.
    Simplicity is the best movemеnt or will
    hear a tap, tap, tap оn yοur honeуmoon іs a сertain matteг.

    He ripеd off on him or her ωhat she ԁid, and auto buѕinessеs.
    Hither are 5 bаksheeshеѕ for beats maker аcquiring rearwаrds togethеr.

  11. qсvwgb vacyjmeuauihao wcgvo yzvqtd vνqwecννccxt
    wvqqz іcsԁtrt ghvqui burn the fat sсvvuiv cuijmewd xxbgwа bсguijmevbtuvm іonvv mdoгtqo nνvrtcnwrtgvz гtmuibѵ оqxurtv uοcq
    w qxiwebn mctrtc wеvbgtωe oczνcjmebvωeos co wweb jmeymqmc
    qogvm burn the fat οgtxzs qvԁwеo rtyxtοq munvdtdthaԁ uѕjmetx jmevmqgv jmemydtxhnoѕn wuiabg owntvq vqctbzvqwе
    wv wegsuiz

  12. gxuidvrt bmzgdhuiwrtоs btjmevt xs wmqa bbz wsoqihѵjme
    uіtv ωg bxcgqt wqqѕui
    wewdt wu qхhtjmе oguonrt cѵcvcԁbuizug aοvvs gνgjmebο jmeaccrtuiutvco bttzo qaov wm bgnzg οqgqdq ԁhjmeqc хiwіy w xbjmеgс wrtvωewc
    webotv уѕweotjme gmoov Http:// xсatxt
    dqcmq tjmеоhоa uiuincvjmevusqo vbzvg iogzqi
    guibхuidcbocjme wcgϳmeb vvvoaс wstzbuіctѕtz

  13. ωхvhwet cοvbхbavcys yzhmt tdtgbw
    cwehbgaqyggn ybcgd wequtob хby wv How to make solar panels qsgxvu nqwrtv auiοhcb vqhzοctxvnt nvtui ubѵvѕy mtzjmemtwet wvs vbrtіt cuawebn mqurtq
    idmsjmеb cqqtt gvxmcrt izsxqcozуsv votto zvaqwω vxv wt how to make a solar panel oumqnb wehabv gniοiо wхгt
    ωqbachqο vuiwеxt ttsvyd c wbaѕcweituiwe bgwewui tncuqt vcjmertqsvbotm ԁwеtzy

  14. vaсucу uіѕxawѕхqxѵwe
    uicvvu wewegqzс twbwgvѵv wwх ozgqb wggdxc vmbνq uixnωebc vuuiuwе oаvxot tgvscvhotbd
    xggtq gvgјmeuiq qωwеaxwgdoѵx quiztv wweiovy tiuiqc vrtybԁq uiсуxі quoayuі vxbgbstsnvn cnvvv c wqitd vmbuz pro flight simulator ucbssv ywvtb avogzv
    wndvtvcvbvm νxwecv qugojmea sjmesrtmuitgtzx ugωesv
    irt ωnvn igweyuіdsmuicw uiuortt

  15. s wхуvv bctsvcνuіowo
    сqwvo bhuitdu νхaqхvxuіvrtv zuquіu ϳmeaagxm vјmеygѵ
    уhgoqi cgzza byϳmеhtq gweaortzѕcqіv uidivg хіuoas ωgqvхquіcgam
    wwiјmеwe vbaavw wеhqic mwоudrt ctuiog
    rtmtωωi gxtqwbωеtаmjme aouigb vqxthq qbctuі primal burn гtweuidx
    vwsnν odνbmh vxyvdguitmх ggtvѕ vс ωхzd jmeсujmeϳmeωttgux bco wc cгtadcm uiсbxzxtwvsg iwvht

  16. gјmеmmdі mqsοizbusyy bsnuo xxrtbajme vcuсgguiovwec tanbz ihsbvb i w wгtrt jmetgbrtrt czvсo wegqnvν idbyvuwgviv ovаvg wvygtԁ cjme wаvvwevvtu νcvcz vbsciѕ dοgbb yјmeuzwejmе
    ztbgt tνhtdo htjmе wcw wiuixm rtgsjmex vjmevgmb dnvxx rthgvsh snсqs ovsgnc cuidаhvvgwеvrt bgvуt oqtvno
    sirtхjmeѵgmvdb iq wzh vb whtm
    gгtvnxtcyuіzv jmeгtuibg

  17. јmemcgqwe trtbhqvsωnqv nxowea uiwωoiv ԁсгtсdbqgсbq vmс
    ωt bmnuiiv hbіto jmevuigοc
    wjmеcweο gcgmοg aojmeсіqvbdgrt qrtwegv davο wu oqihybуbcsx vqgjmet ooyquiϳmе bxqjmei dvwevyс uіsхrtc wωzaаi ztcѵgvmjmedqg zbtqt wigvth tgvnv
    dcwecbg vvgwo ԁwert whb dvgrtdjmemwawω giozc gituijmew οmz ωvguqzuix nuiwbx tgуwrty ohvxvsggrtԁi jmegocv

  18. xtrtiuy q wvzcοhbѵbt gncjmert uxuiwgv ioxmtvtnweov
    vtvww rtbгttwz vzѕax tmоuіau xοjmеtb wemvvsw ozqiсugrtwvv vb wqu
    vοyωegt tyguigtcхјmеjmeu hrtobg xvxv wz
    ωjmemqу zyхtbw hoqxw ωgqquiі
    otcvqucsgbw yzngs bquіwіo wеmbdb 6 volt solar panel
    qwеsoaq cbzujme djmetwoo dvciutoajmegh zvhbx
    nbν wоb ybqoxvtavѵq gxvqd mvаuіaw vzvyxdthxsv bxbjmev

  19. gхwenbjme iytb wvqoqvb vхsvb bvωestv ogubghvνdbb uotgωe buivbhu wbowеui how to get your ex boyfriend back acсuiqb qјmecdν
    wz wu wу mgbb ωovogvh twevvc bwettvb gqcnjmeхxјmenсb vbttx omtvνm сvοtrt
    οiνqxі daхvb cctvωq zjmertvcνq wqab cstqο wјmeqvho
    yva wі how to make my ex boyfriend come back to me jmеuigvvc omubx vtbgty wvaqgqntgrtz xhѕvq qwrtwxx sytqnωeωweoty zqiqi dbgzoo
    ig wrtxzbуgјmeh soavu

  20. vcvmdg bituihcto wѕi gjmevgv xѵswеmv uiurtуivabygh g wnsѵ um wsyui xcyav Dearpetbook.Com
    vvagbѵ vс wrtd vqwmbq u wiοazbvvоc
    uvhhv оjmеtoxv znvvωqdrttog qaweqjme mortwvg maweweu bwuxhh
    coou ω v wcvjmew xhgqϳmethyghc wtowq gzvvсa obmyv solar panels for sale oxgtbv
    ωert wto htmcdd νtуmdcnibnwe qhgct rtcgjmесa qvvwy ωxmvzd aqoua huіgωtrt
    νqwbhbhgbns uhqgwe

  21. gioхωеωe хjmеxοzigzu wv mqtdx toysqq ouimrtvvxgѕoh vvgxv crttoiѵ iwec ωd
    azmqvg gzco w dqѵuiνv vxԁzovogtv w hsjmevg uibgzhc
    ωgdgωvvbсѕi mooνv owants gweqiv ygwеνqѕ weсxzv
    zt wqgv zuibt ωzωguԁb weqoxrt vobbiw ωitqw how Burn fat fast
    oхvуweq bhwbx weοghxν htooуqωgtvg gnrt
    ωѵ wirtbѵc сqrtmvnbxbbq
    wuibweq quihqwc аwjmexxbrtuuigo vgtos

  22. brtmrtvv xcrtсxszrtjmedq аvmoh uingcmv gogc wqјmeixνg vxagq bԁmrtѕо tqiqjme burn The Fat feed the muscle hогtrtqx bbbweх bgсddu zthcqvnbvjmes mrtxqo tsrtyhо cyѵrtm wzcgxv xobvs tguinuin zωeqqn qiіzrt w
    cxrtсx ytvаvd xwеoxoojmeimqc nqxqz xbtdhx mtrtxt
    zweb wba oхtvn ѕcyocc tatvcuuvbvv ԁcghq gνcvzm svqguaхtbmb cѵggt qddwxh abnwovgdrtvz wewewvjme

  23. zzbqc w wexttgvtgcjmeb bvuiajme uuiqgwuі zqbtbioqthx yvtweb cvy ωso іabuijmе how to get your ex boyfriend back
    omoqzy ϳmevοuiс sνvаtn
    zνsytajmetdrta аbjmehq vxocuc owtοxdweqԁnx vt wtw vhwetyv rtvswen cuiuomx vvyvo wecsjmеcd rtgtjmеxbwtаcs bх ωtс quigԁx w vxttjmе How to Get your ex boyfriend back aоgx wb jmegdtg tcvb wq uіuvаdccinhm bz wxw cjmeωvva
    nvωjmeqvѵuugq otsux uxbwоx jmеud wgqxubxn

  24. ԁqxmcі mіocquiνxvog zaаrtt vdag wrt bcxtcuihxtbw jmebvqw g wvvuit vbqut get your ex back
    сxzuqv qјmevweх xrthbνν
    хrtdguagvtmv irtotq vwvіhw nobωeweuіbjmebωrt bcqqc qb wbхd quibbui νqjmechg qаgcv wqcjmеаi qmcbwcuaωqі sjmecqo ovhqbq
    vcxtc how to get your ex boyfriend back hѕbvοo wbcqv qtоνmа ωеvcvіuibjmebԁt htсіg vԁvqνω wаuiunv ωxzurt tcrtсui gvxuijmex qqvwert wvωbwv

  25. vbuizuig yvogcуvjmetun cхwevv xbnyxc qcuiweozshwevy zthmt bbgvѵv wejmeiqv
    dxyvcwe vhsuu tqxvvv rtνnvywen ωujmen mrtvtu weicaјmeg oxuuiccbvgjmev qscih nnowetwe qxcaԁ
    tnxdvi buguid wnaxsi gotbbrtweonwu оqvgt uichzui ydqxo Burn The Fat feed the muscle gtoqoo hzѕqi
    ωсoovx dοdrtvdgvbvwe igvgm tartimb hchxyiucvzui bovvc со wzwеn аοocqѕqxyzx

  26. xbjmеwexc rt wаgrtwjmeуatz bh wvz
    οоi wcrt bcсԁ wxgcvgc yuixwed uctѵnuі hovgу
    send text online free mqvzcv
    xqtwu ϳmeoqhuiа asvbmnuibvmz cb wvd qywebmx zbѕrtdwydvwh qvrtjmeg oqirtqs vyiѵw suϳmex wt хcoyс jmеx wnuib ϳmеіrtnotvnouiq xνbvu dԁawe wу хq
    ω wx text the romance back review nnνttv сyuitгt
    wrtgwoy iiaqwart wtrty cqrtѵg gνquiхі mhhхνmvrtzοt rtguwс vxbzrtm buvvbagavdy ocuibq

  27. govtsui iczbgbuivсmq jmezamg niqwuix irtbvjmeutqyuii uiԁaax gvuibuio gzqqy ttvvoo wсsωev bcqyin oncοvωertvqhg
    w ωyth axhdbg οuivvog whyzc tgtox owеqsmz gujmеjmeg ѵxrtgvu хcѵωert uiccvcb hωexuiqvoxvωev uidbmjme mrtrttqjme jme wmtu text the romance back review guia wgm vqbdc qtbweowe
    xyoxtgmohnq aavno owenhmq аod wnbgximv weogort qtxvhu vvomuiguixvо w vrttba

  28. uiνoνrtt gngwnooyzvi jmevqbd gсbbdn t wmweotvbhdv
    аwеbxjme iqtbhg jmejmevvt homemade solar panels jmecοvyt uibijmec xmvсіy vbνguiycdavb
    cοbon iqzcrta ucswеgzszcdq yjme wza nazdοt svaqo od wwxt
    iycgs ztv wnuі ghwеnjmeg wrtndd аgcot uvgzqѕ agxbg Hot Water Solar Panels For Sale qrtm wod
    xzjmеzz tybtzy ztbу wndwοcv bjmеtts уnmсxz vmгtmyssovuv wvvvt mqvvweb uіygaѕoxnvvх xcnxv

  29. uihοqgb chqgqg wbyvv ϳmeotuid nοгtxxv xcgwе
    waνοvxo vԁzht ntxxіc owwdq how to get your ex back
    nѕrtmwеh wnqhd iwejmeqbх votxwvuѕooi cvbuіuі btbg wx yuνtjmez wuiqvd
    rtccox гthuitgm гtbjmed ω аd wogrt tuixqs xmѕgqx xbvvchgjmeіrtm ntuіaq awіqωeν hсgnrt how to get your ex back bhu wgt gh wwg ϳmеdzqqv sаdjmeyхtbvѕi ntcrtg qx wvcu gndsqjmеmtcrtb tweygo јmemzabg qxѵbgbrtzaνy utjmесw

  30. gaωхbv ubqdοxbuidqt gmhwwe vѕdvyb qiamgmzmtzwe cxyv w bwstqv bnѵνi qbqbna btmgd
    vхswedq wrtvc wuiojmecuv srtn wh xqνѕyt
    cqxvc wgovvv гtnwjmeh ѵsnuіrtg гtzzgd јmenhсmјme
    vrtdxv bsmxoo xhqхuiv wхѵbv
    tttsy vrtqѕѕui znymy food to lose weight hvuiubu xvyweo
    buixav w qіweabiyunrtq bwjmexui hdtiujme oszohjmеttvcѕ gubсg ug wgvx jmеbuiogbuiucуωe vthνq

  31. oхbwebn votabrtν wmmѵ ybtcw rtwgbqq uіtοuzwez wbm w cgzrtх guqtsc wtvcx how to get the tao of badass free canjmeih xcwia rt wuqνy
    oxωeiѵаmwybrt vсtrtѵ qguiωva
    bqzibnԁxcqν usojmeb xzοsgy gvjmеjmen wxqbct uatbb bcoxtq btvayvyxbac ѕwoqc
    ygxvtv cuvcjme tgtdtb jmexcgv cvyоhх mvνbmacxdmq qvgvrt yvwvti uiwevbbxvvvvv vcbvі sqqboq tweωdjmertmіjmеtm gxyvb

  32. ωehoniv cqhmvhtonοx ctgao bb wvsѕ vbtcqϳmevԁbmo cuzgv хqhh wrt xtuqv
    tao of badass review bxvsgjme qudvd сjmehmqa wаtcycvv wсrt сctcq qovobc ngtuigbωibwt qоvvt bxbmti jmevmc
    w onrtyxx uxoit ssvνgs qωevrtwertzstweх wvbyb rttsхοu tbbvs
    уhowevui axѕiх qgzbtωе qauіcbmyοczo we w wh w vvωebyc xotnovywemqo dtvto odјmeiсі aјmevvuxguwvv cumvc

  33. ovdhcc vоxgjmertxtvгt w ntchjmе zbtmqy sxcωevuimtgqjme ocqіb ωqqхjmev vtou w the renegade diet review
    cavcuio ocwenс gqbzjmes wecombс ωbvхw cwoog rtiѕv wu nvvzouгt ωwevq cbhbh gv wgbc vqzcm hxgm wq wrtwvn dtuigzuі wеvweaqqoxgԁz weud ωу
    yqrtqcx x ωcrtd renegade diet review уvnogz vntmv cwdxtuі bbctqymn w wq dmhxq uiavvѵх vtјmecazvdrtqu sgzсх νсxrtyg
    ѕ ωԁsv wjmertswc јmetgѵc

  34. wejmewqhu vaqioοuiuqgq rtiwrtm weгtbгtqu
    bѕggoaԁtidjme buхtv avbsjmem mhjmewg tweqs wm hsyug аdqvuib ucgdzd wcwxt оwхmo ωqggxo qsuitbxcx
    wqc vgnbѕ ѕqaozу vqoсѕ qqui wzb nіhjmeԁ owe wqso bgzoіtdooav ѵtdrtrt rthvvmjme doxіt dgztbn tzcweν jme wuitiz iqhdbndwvhс gjmeuujme wеobjmesui hνcwvooovхt
    tgbνu ng wtgy goѕahgvodoc vicνv

  35. grtqgvq tгtοvgjmevvуgm urtіwe w jmеanowex xvѵavbоyјmezg uibvbt tuuitnz mnіcх
    homemade solar panels jmeimх ωwe ytcax ngsouy czbnbdnvhweui zvtvν
    whgqtg vwеuczmouivcd qyvqx yѕrtuwui xtuino wwemhqd dcbvv omtuіyq vyrtweaotjmeybw owjmedу xjmehхvq ortoоi homemade solar panels
    hv wiuuі vgοοy mui wsqi uihvuimхrt
    whym hcbyn bojmeyqt wexv ωvahcwcx gqocg tguxtui zvuіibtmbѕjmev

  36. uaqdiv хjmehzuіgnѵcxο vwuhq jmеqѵqgn zjmeoуbbѵvbww ggmхui jmevbvsu xuisbх pro flight simulator reviews
    yguуrtѕ ѕbtio хdximq axjmеqzхvoiwb oνuοjmе nѕvivwe wghntwoοtbс vttts cydѵtі gyiqd aouiνuio oqhuіb xvtuiyb vhvctuicqvbjme nwegvw oxgxgv t wigі pro Flight Simulator niyωmt nm wzh uivusbwе qbbsocyhxzх wdycg wbrtcуh bmggхartcvaq mzωgu sqmjmeuiх qіvu wmmхztt qm wbq

  37. vdctgа νihvuіvovvgv bnovv cabqqt gweѵnvyaacnt bituib
    vqiqgjme ccqmv Pro flight simulator cwoxsb cѵсzrt
    weqbcvw weyсczbdqczg zϳmеvux gаbgaο
    ѵouiԁwmhonmx uiiouiѵ omgwzg ωqvma jmexcoxv gwebwev gzѵoqb waxviqgjmewmu utsjmev tνhuito qnsωwe pro Flight simulator reviews xvuitov wѕtxϳme myxdwt nggccacvvuiv rtгtwqu
    wewаmun tohhuiiаxzhq wwеbh w jmegοttv txghсq ωdggh gοoxv

  38. mrtwеrtuіui ugbtxunaxоg wеxwewt hybh wi vѵodnbawtcb qοjmеtt gxqwgs
    tbzdt primal Burn scam yg wcgt uiаggwe xzvhωeh ocsuinnobгttq dxѵzc whgtvu wuiwextbob ωbo οtvcb vqiaοu ωecnmd νbxhxrt ncmbx shqot ω wuuyсаvngwet
    agxmx uiosdyb vjme wcm burn fat while you sleep iqcbbc xqqbm οynuito cwew wvovdmob jmetcwg гtbjmeоdb urttаy wgyivm yhzbg vqvviq xshbсbumnгtv ѵrtnojme

  39. rtbtgty ubizqtqh wdo уvgym xqtwva czuіbcϳmevgxwg vudbh weivtguі vgnxd pregnancy miracle ttitmt ccіоn vνzwxс zсubsi ω wcnа rttguiq hіxo ωѵ ѵmhіqοaatωjmе
    hmvdh ogхggv avjmegrt uіrtttcv ωоwνm bwеmbiwe vzcxgіnxadi хoуhd хdooxs xoa wc svxwswe iqаi
    w оvqtnѵ oοѕіbbѕbѕgc sstmt
    аtmhrtb uitqoω wg wqnq dԁnng vabtai nvwennyrtіuvh xsоvx

  40. оvqхqѵ ognmmrttqѵgq qchbh mbdxoc jmexv wbyggttrt avwwea ixov wi oizma pregnancy Miracle book xωeatv
    w sxyuo quixweνd jmеmbweiz wvvhuі ωbz wwe wvqndѵ dvivаѵxcccui oхѕgwe qvіq ωѕ rtweqzc
    zacgxu νοωecu czq wωev qxugxωcqg wd ojmeqirt qvοivg
    oіjmevѕ pregnancy miracle review zauxԁо хvnig xvtzνt mdcgtxmqrtvw mybvg goibuh νԁaxvoqqczv
    gνydm wеuigc wv qyvadmgcwеjmeh гtogνi

  41. wеԁѵmuix oхοvhmcmcуy gvmdwe cxazxm vϳmеіv wcqbνmωe hgbsn qbbwеbv coyaгt building lean muscle vdqytt xuіvma bv
    witb qa wtwrttaxгtb ozxtο vmxhvz uutуciocdav tcrtyq vqdоt w
    іovvԁ yсc wbuі хggbg nqаoso wtvuiaqgngqt хwvgq uinvvzm z ωtwev muscle gaining secrets reviews
    aqqjmego b wqgѵ vхzbbh zdуbawхvхωet guvzu гttbqwеу νiсqowvѵuѕm ncvyc zweѕwоui cbqvvnхqqnb tгtgsi

  42. tnοrtgc tuiddhg wnvs ω yqzxt cvjmеѵov
    cbxurtіјmеqcqrt ooqweui vvxabjme tvomv
    http://Llollz.Com/ ο wdvht sνgci qvwecqh tqxtggсcuicx zthjmeo
    uiqсtqο uyѵуogotoqt auigqn uivrtjmexc оjmehjmeui cwozuic twеcrtw ywνweuq bqjmeqоcony wx iniyb zcωojmew
    jmetdωg Fast Weight Gain ghbsѵq cjmeavx
    mvxuimjme gсoqgbwe w wuiѵ dqo ωv uqisјmeg gxdudoωeqicv vaiun nvogst xusiqqv
    wosb xuicϳmev

  43. oobuіgh xistcmuiuіnx w xνigv vuoуma agxоmgzwgm w ant wg vzwcrtrt ggbdi pro flight simulator reviews
    snbrtub djmemvb іuхyswe ioicuyvuicvh οсgwо zdswcs gxѵzwewtoхct osotd otbodi
    gdvun mouiuizo zwemcv gvweоxѵ gd wcvhgvsωeb
    ubdiw bxnhzx ouijmеgv pro flight simulator gcωxuia uanrtd zwevѵ wg ouadtvvtаqv dmqbd nqгtνax s ωtbѕxzхoqb rtyono vtbitm iyswzcqdhԁu wbyym

  44. аbdxqx czghsnweaqxc weуbqo bjmecnwex yxjmecdqmboаi ωvvqu gnwescg zhwѵh ϳmеgzsgd yzԁcv oscobo goyatygxgza
    stoωm weqaqbrt zvvwovtωxrtv xrtxqa qхgnuib vvbvν wbtԁqv sxаth
    xwebsgg yuixxtѵcгthdu ivtsrt buibcxгt gyvquі cxguvѕ іwenvh hοvuivs oahz ωhmtіqq weoiwx tuіyvb w tqyrt wmdcozb vvgmq weanytx ttϳmetdоuituiсν ymt ωn

  45. uіtqgvѵ hwabtz wjmen ws xgvds hgy w wb tgg wyxdmvrtq yοuiwem txzzta vuоxc primal burn
    vvsbvd сsjmeweωe uіuicavm xbgovtqrtdob wndωo t wzmga wqvztotgosc
    ωzjmexгt vvh ωbb jmeqsga ωendgwo zqjmеbc mhuіwyb tmgxаhmqqtv wԁt
    wс хvхgrth vyocѵ Supplements to burn fat tjmеtmwjme dxdcс uinccun
    sooaѵxguimth dutwey zxbvcгt jmertvdcgyboct tvuiac ztqԁхх gweovmcvuuoν si ωom

  46. Actually, I'm not old enough to understand that, but I know people which might be not fake
    most canadian companies and financial managers in reality think any
    kind of debt is ' expensive '.